Entellium: A costly lesson in corporate governance |
Connect with TechFlash on our Facebook page for all the latest technology news headlines and commentary, plus information and access to special events, photos from events, promotions and more.
More than $50 million in venture capital down the drain. Over 200 people out of work. And two Internet executives -- both fathers -- going to federal prison.
That's the ugly aftermath of Entellium. Last month, former CEO Paul Johnston and former CFO Parrish Jones were sentenced to two and three years in prison, respectively, for inflating revenue figures over a period of four years at the Seattle software company.
The case, which has left a lingering black eye on the Seattle startup community, has raised questions about the role of the board. Why didn't directors discover the fraud sooner? Where was the audit? And when the board's audit requests were denied, why didn't they push harder?
Corporate attorneys in Seattle say the case has served as a wake up call for directors at privately-held companies. And they say it has reinforced the importance of financial oversight and audits.
"I find it difficult to understand how something like this could happen if the board is properly executing its oversight function," said Stephen Graham, an attorney at Fenwick & West in Seattle. "You want to be pretty darn sure of yourself before you decide that you are not going to require audited financials. And if you have a situation where you have asked for them and you are not getting them -- and this goes on for some period of time -- isn't that a red flag? If this is any kind of a watershed moment, I think it is more of a vivid reminder that boards have real jobs and jobs that need to be taken seriously."
James Judson, an attorney at Davis Wright Tremaine, agreed.
"The key is never to back off from vigorous inquiry," said Judson, who sits on a number of public and private company boards. "Management will sometimes regard board persistence as insubordination, but nonetheless, all information must be thoroughly vetted. Popularity is not required."
The responsibilities at public and private company boards are virtually the same, said Graham. And he said it is surprising how often directors don't take the job seriously.
"Broadly speaking, there are many, many directors out there who see sitting on a board as more of a privilege than a job," he said.
But no matter how hard directors work, Graham said they still can fall victim to fraud.
"With any relationship there is some element of trust, and if you are dealing with people who are bent on defrauding you, more than likely that is going to happen," he said.
That was a key argument in the Entellium case. Carl Blackstone, the Assistant U.S. Attorney, argued that Jones and Johnston abused their positions of trust by lying to the board.
"When they've got the CFO in their board room telling them these are the revenues of the company, do you really think the company needs to say: 'Well, maybe the CFO is lying to me?' Of course, not," said Blackstone. "They trusted him, they relied on him and he abused that trust."
Defense attorneys for Jones countered in court documents that the responsibility fell on the shoulders of the board, including representatives of Ignition Partners which held two seats.
"If any of the investors had even glanced at Entellium’s financial statements, much less completed an audit, the misrepresentations would have been immediately exposed," they said.

At a continuing education seminar for corporate attorneys in Seattle yesterday, the Entellium case remained a hot topic of dicussion.
Len Jordan, a venture capitalist at Frazier Technology Ventures, said its typical at board meetings to have members of the executive management team -- beyond the CEO and CFO -- providing updates on the product development, sales or other matters. If that had occurred with Entellium, Jordan (pictured) said it may have surfaced the inflated revenue figures sooner.
"It just creates open transparency, which is what you want," he said.
The incomplete audit at Entellium remains one of the big mysteries of the case, one that Fenwick & West's Graham believes will have lasting impact.
"One bit of fallout from this is I think people will be more diligent in requiring audits and making sure they get done," he said. Even so, some corporate attorneys at yesterday's legal seminar said that audits are now being pushed aside as an added business cost in these tough economic times.
At the sentencing hearing last month, U.S. District Judge Richard Jones said the board couldn't make proper decisions because they weren't given accurate information.
"The test is not whether investors have the ability to call for inspection or the option of requesting the audit of Entellium's books," Jones said from the bench. "The real issue is that persons holding positions as CFOs have a duty to provide reliable and accurate information, and certainly not fraudulent or misleading information."
If you are commenting using a Facebook account, your profile information may be displayed with your comment depending on your privacy settings. By leaving the 'Post to Facebook' box selected, your comment will be published to your Facebook profile in addition to the space below.
Follow, like, and connect to a broader audience for your company!
The Puget Sound Business Journal announces Social Madness: A Corporate Social Media Challenge, presented by Capital One Spark Business. This a local and national challenge that will spotlight the best social media programs of companies in 43 cities. The local challenge begins (following the nomination period) on June 1, 2012. The promotion will culminate in a national bracket challenge that will crown Social Madness champions in 3 categories based on company size. To see the official rules, visit http://www.socialmadness.com/rules.
For more information on how your company can participate, visit the nomination page here. Nominations are due May 15th.
BizDev Seminar Series - Leadership: Rallying People to a Brighter Future
Join us for this one-of-a-kind seminar series where you hear directly from the experts about hot topics to grow your business.
The skills to be effective as a leader can be learned. What are the skills and attributes needed to be effective top leaders? How do you tell what level your people are at, and what development skills each person needs? Workshop attendees will learn the answers to these questions and more.
Tuesday, May 17, 2012
8:30am - 10:30am
The Harbor Club, Seattle
Register here.