Allen sues Google, Apple, eBay, others over defunct lab's patents |
Connect with TechFlash on our Facebook page for all the latest technology news headlines and commentary, plus information and access to special events, photos from events, promotions and more.
A tech licensing company controlled by Paul Allen is suing eleven Internet and retail giants — including Google, Apple, Facebook, Office Depot, Yahoo, YouTube, Netflix and eBay — alleging that they're violating patents on “fundamental web technologies” developed by Interval Research, the now-defunct Silicon Valley lab that Allen created with Xerox PARC veteran David Liddle in the 1990s.
Noticeably absent from the list is Microsoft, which Allen founded with Bill Gates. Also missing is Amazon.com, the Seattle e-commerce giant that just moved into a new headquarters campus developed by Allen’s Vulcan Inc. in Seattle’s South Lake Union neighborhood.
The allegations are laid out in a complaint filed in federal court in Seattle this morning by Allen’s Interval Licensing LLC, identified as the current holder of Interval Research’s patents. Update: Here's a copy of the complaint: PDF, 15 pages.
[Follow-up: A closer look at the patents at issue in the case]
The suit puts a particular spotlight on the lab’s role as an early source of funding and collaboration for search giant Google. One of the attached exhibits is a screenshot of a September 1998 version of Google’s “About” page, which identified Interval as an outside collaborator along with the IBM Almaden Research Center, and as a source of research funding along with the NSF, NASA and DARPA.
The full list of defendants: AOL, Apple, eBay, Facebook, Google, Netflix, Office Depot, OfficeMax, Staples, Yahoo, and YouTube.
Paul Allen
A total of four Interval Research patents are cited in the complaint, which seeks unspecified monetary damages for alleged patent infringement. In a statement this morning, Allen’s firm calls the patents at issue in the suit “fundamental to the ways that leading e-commerce and search companies operate today.”
The patents cited in the suit include one for a “Browser for use in navigating a body of information, with particular application to browsing information represented by audiovisual data” (USPTO 6,263,507); two patents for an “Attention manager for occupying the peripheral attention of a person in the vicinity of a display device” (USPTO 6,034,652 and 6,788,314) and one for "Alerting users to items of current interest.” (USPTO 6,757,682).
We're reaching out to the companies for comment, and we'll provide updates as we receive responses.
Update, 1:30 p.m. Facebook said in a statement, "We believe this suit is completely without merit and we will fight it vigorously."
The social network is alleged to be violating one of the four patents cited in the suit. Some of the other defendants are alleged to be violating multiple patents.
Follow-up: Google chides Allen over lawsuit
The suit says Interval won some 300 patents in less than a decade of existence. The lab closed in 2000, after coming under pressure to develop more marketable products from its research projects.
“Starting with Mr. Allen, Mr. Liddle, and a handful of scientists and inventors, Interval Research evolved into one of the preeminent technology firms,” the complaint says. “It employed over 110 of the world’s leading scientists, physicists, and engineers, and was at the forefront in designing next-generation science and technology.”
Allen left his full-time role at Microsoft in 1983, well before the company’s move into the Internet. His wide-ranging digital ventures and investments since then have produced decidedly mixed results. Allen remains a shareholder in the Redmond company and remains a friend of Microsoft Chairman Bill Gates.
Microsoft became an even bigger player in the search business just this week -- taking over Yahoo’s underlying search operations to become the No. 2 search provider behind Google in the U.S.
In a statement, Allen spokesman David Postman called Interval Research “an early, ground-breaking contributor to the development of the internet economy.” He added, “Interval has worked hard to bring its technologies to market through spinning off new companies, technology transfer arrangements, and sales of its patented technology.”
Asked why Microsoft or Amazon wasn’t named among the defendants in the suit, Postman declined to comment on litigation strategy. However, he noted that only a handful of Interval’s hundreds of patents are cited in the suit, and said today’s complaint isn’t necessarily the end of the actions that Interval Licensing might take.
"This is the most recent step in a long process," he said in an email, "but it is not necessarily the end of the process."
[Follow-up: A closer look at the patents at issue in the case]
If you are commenting using a Facebook account, your profile information may be displayed with your comment depending on your privacy settings. By leaving the 'Post to Facebook' box selected, your comment will be published to your Facebook profile in addition to the space below.
Who's creating today's energy efficient buildings? Find out at the BetterBricks Awards, Feb. 16
BetterBricks Awards salute the individuals leading the way for high performance commercial buildings with an emphasis on energy efficiency. Join us as we recognize these standout green building professionals.
Award categories include: Advocate; Architect/Designer; Facility Manager/Operator; and Owner/Developer.
Keynote Speaker: Kevin Kampschroer, Director of U.S. GSA's Office of Federal High Performance Buildings. Kevin leads the U.S. General Services Administration's efforts in building sustainability and accelerating industry adoption of sustainable principles across all aspects of a building's life.
Register here by February 10!
If you are interested in buying a table, email Monica Alquist or call her at 206-876-5404.
The Triple Door Presents: The Atomic Bombshells "J'ADORE!: A Burlesque Valentine"
Seattle's reigning Burlesque super-troupe delivers a gorgeous and glittering VALENTINE featuring some of the Bombshells' most exhilarating acts to date. J'Adore! promises to celebrate l'amour with good humor, style, and a healthy dose of dazzle! Bring a friend, a lover, a family member, or a secret crush, and celebrate with the Valentine's Burlesque spectacular that will leave you shouting: "J'ADORE......The Atomic Bombshells!" The incomparable Jasper McCann emcees with high style and charm.
Please visit www.thetripledoor.net for a full schedule of future performances.
The Triple Door Presents: Bob Mould – See A Little Light: An Evening of Reading and Music
"Bob Mould. Those two words are synonymous with integrity. From Husker Du in the last century to right at this moment, Bob is the real deal, writing and playing music for music's sake. He's a great songwriter and performer. I have been a fan of Bob's for thirty years now with no end in sight." -Henry Rollins
Please visit www.thetripledoor.net for a full schedule of future performances.
Why Choose BDO for your SOC (previously SAS 70) Reports?
BDO’s experience in providing attestation services (SAS 70/SSAE 16, AT 101, AT 201, AT 601, etc.) to a broad range of industries, and our team of skilled professionals distinctly qualifies us to serve as your company’s Service Auditor. By leveraging the BDO global network of control specialists, we are poised to provide global services in more than 1,000 offices and across 119 countries. Many organizations find that investing in reports on controls may result in benefits, including:
• Increased client confidence
• Improved competitive advantage
• Minimization of frequent audits
• Streamlined business processes and controls
• Enhanced risk management
For detailed information contact Paul Martini at pmartini@bdo.com.